Have you ever seen the body builders at the gym shaking their blender bottles filled with protein shakes? Protein powder is all the rage these days for muscle building and getting lean, but as a Registered Dietitian Nutritionist, I’m here to give you the low-down on protein powders. Despite what marketing may tell you, protein powders may not be necessary for everyone. We created a guide to help you determine if protein powder is right for you (and which is the best protein powder to choose if you need it).
Things to Consider When Adding Protein Powder into Your Diet
Protein is one of three main nutrients we get in the foods we eat. Carbohydrates and fat are the other two main nutrients. Each main nutrient has specific roles on our body. Carbohydrates provide energy for work and play. Fats offer concentrated calories and help with absorption of fat-soluble vitamins. Protein is for muscle building and repairing tissues.
The problem most people face is that they think more protein is better for more muscle building. They’ll pack in the high protein foods like meats, eggs, dairy, protein shakes, protein bars, and anything else that says “high protein” on the label. Here’s the thing: Whatever protein our bodies don’t use for muscle building and repair gets used up as energy or worse: stored as fat on our bodies! What’s the point in over-consuming protein if our body won’t use it like you want it to do?
How much protein do I need?
While protein is an essential component of our diet, we have to consume enough carbohydrates and fat so that our body doesn’t pull on the protein we eat for muscle building. So what’s the right amount of carbohydrates, fat, and protein? How do you know if protein powders are right for you?
According to the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, most adults should consume 45-65% of their calories from carbohydrates and 20-35% from fat. Protein should only make up 10-35%. It is important that these recommendations are achieved; otherwise you may be using protein for energy and not for muscle repair. For more information about how carbohydrates, fats, and proteins all work together for proper muscle building, click here.
Who would benefit from protein powder?
If protein is not supposed to be the highest source of calories, how do you know if you need protein powder? Below, you’ll find examples of when protein powder is a good option to include in your diet:
- Vegetarians or vegans who struggle to consume enough protein-rich foods
- Athletes who need to replenish after a tough workout, but who can’t squeeze a meal or snack into their schedule within an hour after exercising
- As a meal replacement when you don’t have time to eat
- Part of a breakfast smoothie or shake to increase the nutrition of that food item
- People with increased protein needs like the elderly, malnourished patients, or cancer patients
Talk to a local Registered Dietitian (RD) to find out if you are meeting your specific protein needs. If you are still interested in incorporating protein powders into your diet, we’ve got the short list for you to help you navigate the complex protein powders market. In this article, you’ll learn about the best protein powder to add to your current diet and exercise regimen. You will also learn how to choose the best protein powders for your needs. We included great-tasting recipes that use a combination of ingredients and the best protein powder for building muscle!
What Types of Protein Powder are Out There?
Amongst the thousands of protein powders out there, there are several categories to choose from: dairy-based, plant-based, whey protein, organics (and even more). It is important that you think about which type of protein powder aligns with your diet and your taste buds. What are the best protein powders for men? Are there different products that are the best protein powders for women? What about for age?
Here is the Registered Dietitian’s list of the best protein powders and our guide detailing how to select the best protein powder for you. Be sure to check out our “Protein Powder Recipe and Tips” section below for recipe ideas and other tips on how to incorporate protein powder seamlessly into the diet.
Best Whey Protein Powder
Whey Protein Powder (Vanilla) by Swanson Health
- 90 calories per scoop
- 16 grams protein
- Low sodium
- Low fat
Who Makes It:
Swanson Health was established in 1969 in Fargo, North Dakota. A man named August Swanson, an immigrant to the United States, suffered from joint pain and wanted to find alternative ways to relieve his pain. Today, Swanson Health makes several different protein powders like cow-based whey, goat-based whey, and pea protein. They offer gluten-free, kosher, organic, non-GMO, and cruelty-free products.
The Bottom Line:
Are you looking to add some flavor and protein to your breakfast shake? Then this is a great choice for you since this whey protein powder is lower in calories, fat, and sugars than other brands. This is also a good choice for those interested in losing weight since it only adds 90 calories per scoop.
Best Pea Protein Powder
Sports Pea Protein Powder (Unflavored) by NOW Foods
- 120 calories per scoop
- 24 grams protein
- 0 grams of sugar and added sugar
- Soy-free and dairy-free
Who Makes It:
NOW Foods was established in 1968, making 2018 their 50thanniversary. This brand has won countless awards. NOW Foods has won “Best Places to Work in Chicago,” “Clean Choice Awards,” and “Body Care Award Winner” in 2018 alone. NOW Foods specializes in products like supplements, essential oils, and even dips into the beauty and pet care realm. Aside from producing and their achievements, NOW Foods also takes pride in their charitable donations to Hurricane Harvey relief funds and other natural disasters.
The Bottom Line:
This protein powder would be great as a meal replacement shake for those days when you don’t have time to eat. It is also great for athletes who are in a time-crunch and won’t be able to consume a meal within an hour post-workout. NOW’s pea protein powder is safe for people with dairy or soy allergies, but always check the label on how these products are manufactured. Since this is a plant-based protein powder, vegans and vegetarians should consider using this powder. Here’s another great thing about this pea protein powder: since it is unflavored, this powder can be added to water, milk, juice, or any other drink, making this a highly-versatile product.
Best Tasting Vegan Protein Powder
Pure Organic Spirulina Powder by Sari Foods
As mentioned above, vegans may need extra help getting enough protein in each day. This spirulina powder is great for adding into a variety of foods like smoothies, smoothie bowls, frozen treats, pesto, and baked goods. It is a lower-calorie vegan option that is also fortified with vitamins and minerals that vegans may be lacking like iron and B12.
- 40 calories per scoop
- 7 grams protein
- Fortified with 1460% the daily value of B12
- 20% of your daily iron needs
Who Makes It:
Sari Foods is a young company that was founded in 2012. Their products come from plant-based food sources that are rich in antioxidants, essential fats, and micronutrients. This company strives to use “simplicity as the pathway to health and longevity.” Try out their other powders like Sari’s turmeric powder, fiber powder, and beet powder.
The Bottom Line:
Keep in mind that 1 serving of this product is smaller than the servings of other protein powders on this list. This smaller serving size makes it easier to add seamlessly into everyday recipes. If you are a vegan who struggles to get enough protein in during the day, this vegan protein powder with added vitamins and minerals would be a great option to include daily. For more options in vegan protein products, check out this in-depth article dedicated to analyzing vegan protein powders specifically.
Best Organic Protein Powder
Organic Plant Based Protein Powder (Vanilla) by Orgain
Nutritionally, this organic protein powder is a well-rounded and great-tasting protein source that can be implemented in the diet. This organic powder is also great for people with certain food allergies. See the nutritional breakdown below in the “Highlights.”
- 150 calories per 2-scoop serving
- 21grams protein
- 7 grams of fiber per serving
- Dairy-free, soy-free, gluten-free, lactose-free
Who Makes It:
Orgain’s beginnings came from the personal struggle of its founder, Andrew, who suffered from aggressive cancer during adolescence. Many cancer patients like Andrew struggle to keep a healthy weight before, during, and after treatment. Doctors and Registered Dietitians typically encourage high calorie, high protein foods for cancer patients to maintain a healthy weight. In Andrew’s case, however, he wanted to create plant-based, organic, and nourishing food. Andrew’s story continued when he became a doctor and wanted to help patients like him overcome their illnesses. His efforts moved past the hospital where he was working when he created Orgain for the general public. Orgain specializes in protein powders, protein bars, and ready-to-drink protein shakes for adults and kids.
The Bottom Line:
Aside from being organic and free of several of the top allergens, this product is also vegan. This is a well-rounded protein powder suited for virtually anyone who wants to add protein powder into his or her diet. One important fact to keep in mind is that this protein powder is a higher-calorie product compared to the other protein powders on this list. If you’re trying to slim down, use this protein powder occasionally as a meal replacement for a full meal.
Best Low Carb Protein Powder
Isopure Infusions Whey Protein Isolate Powder by Isopure
Some protein powders can have tons of sugar and calories in order to make them taste good. This low carb protein powder differs from the rest of the products on this list for its refreshing berry flavor. Add this protein powder to ice water for a refreshing, juice-like beverage. You’ll be surprised that this power has 20 grams of protein per serving!
- 90 calories per scoop
- 20 grams protein
- Total carbohydrates per serving: 2 grams
- Made with fruit and vegetable juice; sweetened with stevia; contains milk (allergen warning)
Who Makes It:
Isopure was established 30 years ago by two men named Hal and Ernie. They wanted to make nutritional products for active people. It was their dream to create nutritional products that were the “cleanest, purest, and most perfect protein around.” Isopure sells both ready-to-drink beverages as well as protein powders. Aside from nutrition products, they also sell a variety of active gear like shirts, jackets, and backpacks.
The Bottom Line:
If you’re sick of the milky texture and taste of most protein powders, add some variety with this low carb protein powder. Ditch the conventional chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry and try out all the refreshing fruity flavors Isopure has to offer. This would be great for the warm summer months. Experiment by mixing this powder with several beverages like sparkling water, unsweetened tea, and 100% fruit juice. One thing to note: This product does contain milk products (whey protein), so those with a milk allergy should not consume this powder.
Best Plant-Based Protein Powder
Soy Protein Isolate Powder by BulkSupplements
While there are several other protein powders on this list that are derived from plant-based sources, soy protein is a complete protein source, making it similar to animal proteins in eggs, meats, and cow’s milk. With the exception of soy protein, plants do not offer a complete protein profile and must be combined with other plant sources to get all essential amino acids.
- 112 calories per serving
- 27 grams protein
- Less than 1g fat
- Contains soy (allergen warning)
Who Makes It:
BulkSupplements is a nutritional supplement company based out of Henderson, Nevada. They are a hub for various nutritional supplements that support digestion, joint health, beauty, muscle growth, weight loss, and heart health. Also, they sell herbal supplements, vitamins, minerals, and weight scales similar to an online drug store.
The Bottom Line:
This plant protein powder gives you lots of protein in one little scoop since soy protein is a complete protein source. The only downside to this product is that is quite expensive per serving and contains only 3 servings per container. This soy protein powder would be great for someone who has increased protein needs from chronic diseases like malnutrition or cancer since it offers lots of protein per serving. Senior citizens who are at risk of muscle wasting may also benefit from this product to help maintain current muscle mass.
The Secret to Picking the Best Protein Powder for You: Considerations Before You Buy
Now that you have a list of the best protein powders available on the market, you can make an educated (and taste bud approved) purchase in a product that will complement your diet and exercise habits. Here is a guide that details the most important factors in finding the perfect protein powder for you:
Allergens and Hidden Contaminants:
While this may be a given, a reminder to avoid your allergens is never a bad thing. It is essential that you read the ingredients label on all protein powders before you consume them. Aside from what goes into the protein powder, some powders are manufactured in the same facilities where cross-contamination of allergens may occur. This information can usually be found right on the protein powder label near the ingredients list.
One quick note for people with lactose intolerance: Despite the fact that whey protein comes from animal milk, whey protein typically contains zero to minimal lactose. Talk to a Registered Dietitian if you are concerned about lactose in protein powders.
Plant-Based Protein vs. Animal-Based Protein:
Understanding where the protein in your protein powder comes from may be important to you. If you are vegan, stick with plant-based protein like pea, spirulina, and soy protein. For vegetarians, you may feel comfortable consuming either plant-based or whey protein. If you eat a lot of animal products, try out the plant-based protein to add variety in your diet.
Your Nutrient Needs:
Remember that protein powders are not essential to building muscle. Protein powders are items that should be used to supplement a healthy diet, not replace a healthy diet. For people who are trying to lose weight, protein powders can add excess calories if not coupled with a calorie-restricted diet. In those who may need to gain weight, some protein powders may not provide enough calories to keep your weight up. For your specific nutrient needs, visit your local Registered Dietitian.
Protein Powder Recipes and Tips get more Protein in Your Diet
- Protein powders can be used in smoothies, milkshakes, smoothie bowls, baked goods, and anywhere else you can think of. Here’s a single-serving high-protein pancake recipe that works well with nearly any protein powder:
- ¼ cup uncooked oats
- 1 egg white
- ½ scoop protein powder (unflavored, vanilla, or chocolate)
- 1/8 cup berries or cut-up fruit
- ¼ tsp baking powder
- 1/8 cup water
- Directions: Blend all ingredients together in a food processor until smooth. Then pour dollops of pancake batter into a hot pan that has been lightly sprayed with cooking oil. Cook the pancakes on each side until golden brown. Remove from pan and top with fruit, syrup, or other toppings.
- Protein per serving: 22 grams
- Maybe you’re starting to think that protein powder is not essential in your diet, but you still want a high protein breakfast that’s quick and easy. Here’s a recipe for a yummy high-protein PB&J shake that does not require protein powder.
- 1 banana
- 1 cup pea-based yogurt (i.e. Ripple) or nonfat Greek yogurt
- 1 cup unsweetened soy milk or skim milk (more or less for consistency)
- 2 Tbsp nut butter
- ½ frozen, unsweetened berries (i.e. Trader Joe’s Berry Medley)
- Directions: Combine all ingredients in a blender. Add ice and blend if desired.
- Protein per serving: 37 grams
- Allergen Warning: This recipe contains milk, soy, and nuts.
The Bottom Line on Selecting and Adding Protein Powder into Your Diet
As you can see after reading this article, protein powders may be helpful for select populations like vegans, seniors, athletes, and those with a chronic disease that puts them at risk for muscle wasting. For the general public, no protein powder should get in the way of a well-rounded diet that contains adequate carbohydrates, fat, and protein.
If you feel that your needs constitute some form of protein powder supplementation, use the guide and product reviews above to help leverage your search for the perfect protein powder for you. There are a lot of protein powders to try, but hopefully this list gives you a starting point to finding the best protein powder for your needs and your taste buds.
So what is the best protein powder for you? Which is the best tasting protein powder in your opinion? Tell us about your favorite protein powder in the comments below.